top of page

Which Leadership Style is Right for You?

Writer's picture: William C. Rawe, Ph.D.William C. Rawe, Ph.D.

Updated: Oct 26, 2024

Over time, researchers have learned that leadership skills aren’t just something people are born with. While intelligence plays a role, other factors like personality and follower characteristics also impact how effective leaders are. For example, things like job satisfaction and motivation among team members can influence a leader’s success. These findings led researchers to explore various leadership styles, which we’ll discuss before diving into leadership development.



A charistmatic leader guiding his team toward the goal
Charismatic Leader

Charismatic Leadership

Charismatic leaders are known for their ability to inspire others with a compelling vision for the future. They tend to have strong self-confidence, passion, and a dedication to their cause. Followers often see them as having extraordinary abilities, which can lead to high levels of motivation, trust, and loyalty. However, there’s a downside—some charismatic leaders misuse their influence for unethical purposes. While charismatic leadership can drive group success, it may be less effective on an individual level.

Transformational Leadership

Transformational leadership is one of the most popular styles in modern research. These leaders focus on inspiring exceptional performance by encouraging new ways of thinking. Transformational leaders use four key methods: they behave in ways that inspire admiration (charisma), motivate followers with high standards, challenge conventional thinking, and provide personalized attention to their team members. While similar to charismatic leadership, transformational leadership is more focused on ethics and values, which can lead to greater job satisfaction and higher performance for both groups and individuals.

Transactional Leadership

Transactional leadership is more straightforward, based on setting clear expectations and rewarding people for meeting them. It can also involve taking corrective action when performance isn’t up to standard. There’s a debate about whether transformational or transactional leadership is more effective, but it’s clear that both have their place. Success often depends on aligning leadership styles with organizational goals and team dynamics.

Servant Leadership

Servant leaders focus on serving their team members, emphasizing qualities like humility, compassion, and a commitment to others' well-being. This style is less focused on traditional organizational goals and more on the personal growth and emotional health of followers. However, it’s not as widely studied or accepted because it doesn’t always align with business objectives.

Authentic Leadership

In response to concerns about trust in leadership, authentic leadership has gained traction. Authentic leaders are genuine, transparent, self-aware, and highly moral. This style emphasizes building strong, ethical relationships with team members and fostering an environment of honesty and integrity.

Ethical Leadership

Ethical leadership aims to promote moral behavior and create an ethical workplace. Although every leadership style involves some ethical considerations, ethical leaders make it a priority. They act as moral role models and ensure that ethical standards guide their decision-making. However, critics argue that ethical leadership can sometimes be too vague and rooted in Western ideals.



Spiritual Leadership

Spiritual leaders aim to create a workplace environment where followers find meaning and purpose. They lead with love, care for others, and focus on a vision that goes beyond material success. However, this style heavily relies on the leader’s personality, meaning the organization may struggle if that leader leaves.

Shared Leadership

Shared leadership involves distributing leadership responsibilities across a team. This approach works well in complex environments where no single person has all the expertise needed to make decisions. In these cases, team members collaborate to solve problems, creating a more inclusive and effective decision-making process.

 Full-Range Leadership

Many leadership styles overlap, making it difficult to neatly categorize them. For example, charismatic, transformational, and transactional leadership share some traits. Researchers suggest that an integrated approach might be best, combining elements from different styles to create a more effective leadership model for today’s organizations.

Harmful Leadership

Not all leadership is positive. Harmful leadership occurs when leaders act against the organization’s goals, either through abuse, bullying, or toxic behaviors. Abusive leaders may ridicule or mistreat their team, causing harm and reducing motivation. Bullying involves consistent negative behavior over time, while toxic leadership refers to severe and long-lasting damage to the organization. In these cases, leadership development efforts may not be enough to fix the problem, and removing the leader might be the best solution.

Comentários


bottom of page